Do Faraday bags work?
What was actually tested?
The SANS Internet Storm Center is a security group that publishes daily write-ups by its handlers. In May 2023 handler Jesse La Grew posted "Signals Defense With Faraday Bags & Flipper Zero". The write-up names one bag brand and says several bags were used, against several kinds of wireless signal. The test used a Flipper Zero (a hobby radio tool), phones and a laptop.
| Signal | What the author did | Result reported |
|---|---|---|
| Cellular | iPhone in the bag, Android phone called it | The iPhone could not receive the call; the call went to voicemail |
| Wi-Fi | Phone hotspot in the bag, laptop pinging | The network quickly disconnected and could not be seen |
| NFC (credit card) | Card sealed in the bag, reader on top | The reader could not read the card |
| Bluetooth | iPhone playing audio to connected earbuds | Audio cut in and out; the result depended heavily on how well the bag was sealed |
| RFID, 125 kHz (HID card and fob) | Item sealed in the bag, reader on top | The reader was able to read the data |
That is tested, with one named brand, by one person. It does not say every bag behaves the same way.
Is blocking a phone signal the same as surviving an EMP?
No. A phone signal is a low-power radio signal. The E1 part of a nuclear high-altitude EMP is a very fast, very strong pulse. The EMP Commission's 2008 vehicle tests went up to about 50 kV/m (kilovolts per meter). A bag that holds back a weak signal has not been shown to hold back a pulse of that strength, and the SANS test did not try one. The SANS page mentions no pulse testing at all.
Engineering reasoning says a well-closed, continuous conductive enclosure should reduce fields inside it, and that gaps, torn seams and poor closures let energy in. That is expected, not tested for consumer bags. Any gain from a bag also depends on what is inside and whether it was connected to anything when the pulse arrived.
Solar storms are a separate event. The sources we read describe solar-storm effects on long power lines and transformers. We found no source on small electronics, so we do not say whether a bag matters for a solar storm.
A home check, and what it proves
- Put a phone in the bag, close it exactly as the maker says, and call the phone from another phone. Check that it does not ring.
- Repeat with the phone's Wi-Fi hotspot on, and see whether another device can still see the network.
- Repeat with a Bluetooth speaker or earbuds playing, then close the bag in a slightly different way and compare.
- Try again after folding the bag a few times, the way you would store it.
What this shows: the bag blocks those radio bands, at that sealing, with that device. It also shows whether your closing method matters.
What it does not show: anything about an EMP. A strong pulse and a phone signal are different tests. A bag that fails the home check is a poor shield. A bag that passes it has not been shown to survive a pulse.
What does MIL-STD-188-125 cover?
MIL-STD-188-125-1 is a U.S. military standard for hardening fixed, ground-based command and communication facilities against high-altitude EMP. It is not a consumer product standard. A bag or box described as meeting or "certified to" it is a claim to check. Ask the maker for the test report: who tested it, what pulse level, what was inside, and whether it was the exact product on sale.
What we do not know
- Tested: radio-signal blocking of one named bag brand (SANS, 2023).
- Unknown: how any consumer bag performs against E1 pulses. We found no independent test.
- Unknown: how bags age, wear at the seams or hold up after repeated opening.
- Unknown: how small electronics inside a bag respond to a pulse at all. We found no primary test data for small consumer electronics.
What to do about it
- Run the home check above before spending more. Low cost, and it tells you whether the bag blocks those radio signals.
- If a maker cites a pulse test, ask for the report. See what to look for in a Faraday bag.
- Remember that spare items matter more than a perfect bag. See what electronics survive an EMP and EMP versus solar storm.
- Do not buy on the strength of a certification name alone.
Sources
- SANS Internet Storm Center, Jesse La Grew, "Signals Defense With Faraday Bags & Flipper Zero", May 16, 2023. isc.sans.edu/diary/29840
- EMP Commission, Critical National Infrastructures report, April 2008 (vehicle tests up to about 50 kV/m). empcommission.org