Faraday bags: what to look for before you buy
What does a maker's test claim prove?
It depends on what was measured. Two very different tests get described with the same words.
- Radio blocking. A phone, Wi-Fi or Bluetooth device inside the bag loses its signal. This shows the bag attenuates those radio bands. It is easy to run, and you can repeat it at home.
- Pulse exposure. A device inside the bag is hit with a strong, fast pulse and then checked. This needs a test facility. The 2008 EMP Commission vehicle tests, for example, went up to about 50 kV/m.
Passing the first does not show the second. A bag can block a phone signal and still pass energy at other frequencies, or through a seam or closure. Keep three things apart: what a maker says it measured (a claim), what engineering reasoning expects from shielding, and what is unknown (surviving a pulse, for a specific consumer bag). For the wider question, see do Faraday bags work.
What does MIL-STD-188-125 actually cover?
MIL-STD-188-125-1 covers high-altitude EMP hardening of fixed, ground-based military command and communication facilities. It is not a consumer product standard. A bag or box described as "certified to MIL-STD-188-125" is a claim to check, not proof. A fixed facility test and a fabric pouch are different things, so ask what, specifically, was tested and to which part of the standard.
Other standards come up in listings. UL 1449 covers surge protective devices on 50/60 Hz circuits up to 1000 V and is not an EMP rating. None of them, on the page of a seller, tells you a bag was tested unless a report says so.
What questions should you ask a seller?
- Is there a written test report for this exact model, not a similar one or the material alone?
- Which lab produced it, and is the lab independent of the maker?
- What frequencies were tested, from what to what, and was a pulse test run or only a signal test?
- Was the bag tested closed the way you will close it, including the seam?
- Was it tested new only, or after folding and repeated opening?
- What are the measured results, as numbers, not words like "military grade"?
A seller who cannot answer has told you something useful. Makers in this category include MOS Equipment, whose site lists Faraday bags for key fobs, phones, tablets and laptops. This is a plain pointer, not a recommendation, and we have not tested its products.
Closure, size and wear
- Closure. Engineering reasoning expects most signal leaks in shielded pouches to come from the opening and seams. Look for a closure method the maker describes in its test, and follow it exactly.
- Size. The device and any cable should fit without forcing the seam. A bag that is overstuffed does not close the way it was tested.
- Wear. Folded metallic fabric can crack or wear. Ask whether the maker tested after repeated opening, and re-check your bag now and then.
How can you check a bag at home?
This checks radio blocking only. It does not check pulse protection.
- Put a phone in the bag, close it the way the instructions say, and call the phone from another phone. No ring is a pass for cellular.
- Repeat with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth: try a Bluetooth speaker or tracker connected to the phone, then close the bag.
- Try a small battery radio tuned to a station, closed inside the bag.
- Test again after the bag has been opened and closed many times.
A partial result, such as some signals getting through, tells you the bag is leaking at those frequencies.
What we do not know
We found no independent pulse test of a consumer Faraday bag. We also found no primary test data on small consumer electronics surviving a pulse, with or without a bag. Whether a bag that passes a signal test would protect a device in an actual event is unknown.
What to do about it
- Keep backups of what matters (documents, photos, contact lists) on media stored separately. This costs little and works for any cause of loss.
- Decide what a bag would hold before buying. Fewer items means a smaller, simpler purchase.
- Ask the six questions above and keep any report you are given.
- Run the home check, then read do Faraday bags work and what electronics survive an EMP.
Sources
- EMP Commission, Critical National Infrastructures report, April 2008, chapter 6: empcommission.org
- Scope descriptions of MIL-STD-188-125-1 (hardening of fixed, ground-based military facilities) and UL 1449 (surge protective devices) are given as general descriptions of the standards; we did not open the standards documents themselves.
- MOS Equipment, home page, opened 2026-11-21: mosequipment.com (confirms it sells Faraday bags; no performance claim is relied on).