What electronics survive an EMP?
Is there test data on phones, radios and laptops?
We looked for government, national laboratory and standards-body test results on small consumer electronics exposed to a high-altitude pulse. We did not find any. Vendor pages and affiliate roundups make many claims, but a seller's marketing page is not a test, and this site does not cite one as proof. If a published independent test exists, we have not seen it.
What is the nearest tested analog?
The EMP Commission's 2008 infrastructure report describes tests on 37 cars (model years 1986 to 2002) and 18 trucks (model years 1991 to 2003). A vehicle is a metal body full of electronics and wiring, so it is a useful, though imperfect, stand-in. The details are on does an EMP destroy cars.
| Item | Status | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Cars and trucks, 1986 to 2003 | Tested | EMP Commission, 2008. Most had no effect or nuisance faults; engines stopped in some running vehicles |
| Cars after 2003, electric vehicles | Unknown | Not in that test set |
| Phones, radios, laptops | Unknown | No primary test data found |
| Utility digital relays | Tested (studied) | EPRI: moderate E1 could affect about 5%, severe about 15% |
| Unplugged vs. plugged in | Expected | Engineering reasoning, below |
What can be reasoned, and how sure is it?
The following is expected, not tested, and it is general engineering reasoning rather than a finding from a source we read.
- The EMP Commission describes E3 as driving currents in long power lines. Equipment connected to long wires, such as the power grid, is the exposed kind for that part of the pulse.
- A device that is unplugged and has no long cable attached has no long wire to carry such a current. The expectation is that it is less exposed than a plugged-in device. How much less is unknown for the fast E1 pulse, which we have no consumer test data for.
- The car results fit the idea that a lot depends on the particular design. Some cars showed no response and others stalled, so the effect was uneven, not all-or-nothing.
- The EMP Commission says E2 is similar to lightning, which is why a surge protector comes up in this conversation. A surge protector listed to UL 1449 is tested for surge protection on 50/60 Hz circuits up to 1000 V. That is not an EMP rating. Sandia tested grid surge suppressors in 2020 and found they do not protect against HEMP-like pulses (see whole-house EMP protection). We have not seen a test of a household surge protector.
Why does the answer vary so much?
In the vehicle tests, results differed between vehicles. That points to the details of each design (wiring length, shielding, which circuits are exposed) as the deciding factor, and not a simple rule such as "older is safer" or "newer is safer". We found no source that ranks consumer device types, so claims that name specific phones or radios as safe or unsafe have nothing tested behind them as far as we can tell.
This is also why the page does not recommend a particular product. A maker may state it tested to a standard, and that is the maker's claim. Standards such as MIL-STD-188-125-1 cover hardening of fixed military ground facilities and are not consumer product standards, so a "certified to" line on a product is something to check, not proof.
What we do not know
- Unknown: whether any given phone, radio, laptop or charger would work after an event.
- Unknown: whether unplugged devices are measurably safer. This is reasoned, not tested.
- Unknown: whether a Faraday bag or box changes the result. We have not seen an independent pulse test of a consumer bag (see do Faraday bags work).
- Unknown: how a solar storm affects small electronics. The sources we read describe effects on long power lines and transformers (see EMP vs. solar storm).
What to do about it
Because the evidence is thin, the sensible steps are cheap and do not depend on any one answer.
- Keep a spare battery-powered radio that you rarely use, stored away from the wall. See emergency radio: what to look for.
- Keep paper copies of phone numbers, medication lists and maps.
- Store a few essentials in a way that does not depend on any electronics, starting with water: how much water to store per person.
- Before buying a shielding product, read Faraday bags: what to look for, and check what test, if any, the maker cites.
- For power during an outage, see backup power: what to look for. Work inside a home electrical panel is a job for a licensed electrician.
Sources
- EMP Commission, Critical National Infrastructures, April 2008, chapter 6, pp. 114 to 116. empcommission.org
- EMP Commission, Report of the Commission to Assess the Threat to the United States from Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Attack, Vol. 1 Executive Report, 2004. empcommission.org
- EPRI Journal, A Deliberate Approach to Electromagnetic Pulses, 2019. eprijournal.com